Luigi's Mansion Review

By Papermariofan

 
Release Date: November 18, 2001 (First Mario game on GCN)
Developer: Nintendo
Publisher: Nintendo
System: GameCube

Luigi's Mansion was the first Mario (actually Luigi) game for GameCube. Yeah, sure, everyone was supposed to be SO impressed. I really wasn't too impressed myself. I will, of course, rate this Review on a 1-10 scale.

Story: 9
This is one of the best parts of the game. Once again, I look for originality, and this is original. Luigi wins a mansion for some reason and is very excited. He calls Mario to meet him at the mansion. So then he gets there, Mario's gone, and he walks in the mansion. Then a ghost tells him that Mario has been kidnapped. Oh no! LUIGI has to be the hero for a change. I thought this was very unique and different. There were two reasons I took a point off. One was because they NEVER told what type of contest Luigi was in. Second is because the makers made a huge noticeable mistake. If Mario supposedly left behind his belongings and his clothes (which I'll explain later) then why is he in the painting fully dressed? Never made any dog-on sense.

Controls: 1
This game is the worst game I've EVER gone through with controls. Ok, instead of A jumping, it opens doors. Then you get the vacuum. You have to use the C-stick for your flashlight and move Luigi himself with the control stick, PLUS hold R-down to use the vacuum. Now having to do all of this while fighting King Boo is not as easy as it seems. No, you'll find out how hard it is just to control Luigi. You'll find yourself walking sideways at a lot of times, and getting hit in the back by ghosts because you have such a hard time turning around. This game is nothing but a pain to control. Bad job, Nintendo.

Graphics: 10
After pretty much saying the controls are terrible, I've now changed my mind in this categorey. Now the graphics are the BEST I've seen on GameCube yet. Luigi looks amazing, the mansion almost looks real, even outside looks very good. Also there will be scenes every time Luigi opens a door, and it actually shows his hand grasping the key putting it in the hole and unlocking the door. Now the weird thing is it looks like a person wearing a white glove. Yes, a real live person. Nintendo did fantastic with the graphics in this game. This is by far the best part of the game, too.

Music: 4
I like the song that plays through this game. It changes moods depending on which room you are in, and it's sort of creepy. Also you'll find yourself humming it while walking down the hallways at school. Now here's the problem; KEY WORD SONG-SINGULAR. Where's the other songs? Even when you go to save your game it's just a remixed version of it. In fact, the only other songs you'll hear are when a certain ghost plays a classic theme for you on their computer. That's it. I gave this a 4 because I really loved that ONE song. There should have been a lot more music. Also, when you are in the middle of capturing a ghost, the music stops. ???. Oh wait, you do get a small tune from when you have to capture the Boos also.

Gameplay: 8
This is an original way to play a Mario game. Instead of defeating bosses, going through worlds, and defeating Bowser at the end, you actually have to work for E. Gadd to help capture every ghost to fill back in portraits of the mansion. Now this is a lot like the movie "Ghostbusters". Also later on in the game you have to catch several Boos just basically for extra completion of the game. Here's how the game works exactly. You'll go about the mansion sucking up certain enemy ghosts, collecting MONEY, and you also have to suck up boss ghosts. The trick is to flash your flashlight on their HEARTS. When this happens, they won't do anything so now you get a chance to suck up their HP. You also get three elements in your vacuum: ice, water and fire. You'll need these for certain ghosts in the game. This is way different from any other Mario game, which means this gameplay Review gets a good score.

Characters: 7
I had nothing wrong with them really. Mario, Luigi, and Toad were the only returning characters. Then you have new characters such as E. Gadd, all the boss ghosts, and new ghost enemies. King Boo was already used, but not as a final boss. I just wish there would have been a better background for the boss ghosts. It gives a brief bio of them, but doesn't tell a whole lot. I think it would've been cool to unlock an archive showing how they all died and their lives after beating the game. This would have made the dialogue more interesting rather than a brief bio.

Secrets: 2
Ok, another bad part. After beating the game, you basically get nothing. You supposedly get a NEW mansion, but it's actually just the same mansion with a better vacuum. Oh, I guess the optional ghosts are a secret! Plus as you go through the game you collect money. Now what does all this money get you after you beat the game? NOTHING. It's just a record. Like an arcade game, just another recorded score to go in the records. They definitely should have added more secrets. Maybe now you get to play with Mario, and his mansion's completely different from Luigi's? Or maybe that archive idea I had up above. Come on, Nintendo.

Difficulty: 6
The game is almost a 1 in difficulty. You'll breeze through the game because the game is beatable in 2 hours (which means it's way too short). Now here's where the game gets hard. You'll have to face two very hard bosses: Vincent Van Gore and King Boo. These two bosses make the difficulty a 6 because it is so hard to defeat them with the CONTROLS with the vacuum. I beat King Boo on my first try, but then I faced him about 20 times after that, and only beat him 2 out of those 20 times. So, yeah, believe me, that was beginner's luck. You'll have a fun, harsh time at the end of the game.

Replayability: 3
This deserves a 3 because that's all you'll want to do is beat it about three times. Once again, how fun is a game to play again without more secrets, unlockables, etc. You'll do the exact same thing again and again beating your money records. Very boring.

Overall: 6
This game just clears average. There were some great things, yet some awful things. I would spend a maximum of $30. I already explained why the game was great yet terrible at points. I think it's a decent game, really they just needed to make it longer, give it more secrets... oh, but I already mentioned these above.

Did you like this submission?
If you would like to send some feedback to the author of this submission, please complete this form.

What's your name? 
This is required.

What's your Email address?
Only enter this if you would like the author to respond.

How do you rate this submission? 
Please rate on a scale of 1 - 10, 10 being best.

Does this submission belong in Little Lemmy's Land? 
Little Lemmy's Land is designed to include the top ten percent of submissions.

Would you like to see more from this author? 

Comments and suggestions:

 
ZY.Freedback.com: Stunning, fast, FREE!
FREE feedback form powered by Freedback.com
Freedback.com

Want to review a game yourself? Email me!
Go back to Lemmy's Reviews.
Go back to my main page.