James Issac Koopa: Bowser Jr: Well, that solves who stole the cookies from the cookie jar.
James Issac Koopa: The first attempt at making Yoshi's Cookie went wrong due to the first level taking place in Bowser's Castle.

Joshua: Yoshi: ... Awkward moment...
Joshua: Bowser Jr: Hey! We agreed to split the loot three ways!

Pirate-Guy: Larry: Caught you, Yoshi! Well YOU got caught since I put some mouse trap in the cookie jar.

flitchard: Wendy: I hope to DAD they don't find the zipper...

Anthony S. Koopa: Yoshi: Uhh... Come on guys. Happy Christmas? Hannukah? Cookie Day?

Chase: Yoshi: Uh... um... hi? *laughs uneasily*
Chase: Larry: I want in!

the game prince: Bowser Jr: See, Bro? I told you someone was trying to steal my cookies!
the game prince: Larry: WAIT A MINUTE... WHO LET YOU IN?
the game prince: Do you ever wonder what Yoshi does when Mario leaves him to enter a fortress? ***FIRST PRIZE***

polkamon: Yoshi: What? Er, I thought they were, ummm... giant watermelons!
polkamon: Larry: Ludwig, get out of the Yoshi costume.

George 200: Music: "Busted" from Phineas and Ferb.
George 200: Bowser Jr: BUSTED!
George 200: Uh... Isn't it a little late for trick or treating?

warioman: Larry: Wait, if Jr. is standing right in front of my flashlight, where's his shadow?
warioman: Shadoo: Finally, after seaching millions of miles I can eat Anti Guy's cookies and- Drat! Larry and the little Bowser have
warioman: found me. I mean, YOSHI!

Your Twin the Fourth: Larry: Dang this broken flashlight! It disturbs my eyes!

Jalvo the Slime: Larry: This is the fifth time tonight! We steal all the cookies and everyone always wants one.
Jalvo the Slime: Yoshi: (Maybe if I stay real still I will look like a statue. I'll do that!)

birby6: Who stole the cookies from the cookie jar? Yoshi stole the cookies from the cookie jar!
birby6: Black Yoshi: I know what you're thinking, but this is usually a Bandit's job!
birby6: This is why Black Yoshis didn't appear in Yoshi's Story.
birby6: Larry: Hey! You're not the guy from Sesame Street!
birby6: Bowser Jr: Wow. I didn't know Santa was THAT DESPERATE.
birby6: Larry: We were expecting Robin Hood, but you'll have to do.
birby6: Two 7's in the Caption's number actually meant BAD luck instead of good luck.
birby6: Bowser Jr: Why couldn't we just get a pet Goomba like everyone else?

1-up Boo: Bowser Jr: Told you we need to install a laser trap.

Daisyplayer1: Larry: Busted!
Daisyplayer1: Bowser Jr. and Larry don't know that the black Yoshi's putting cookies in the cookie jar.
Daisyplayer1: Bowser Jr: HEY! THOSE COOKIES WERE FOR MY GIRLFRIEND!
Daisyplayer1: Black Yoshi: Uh, hey guys, I was just uh... not stealing one of the cookies from the cookie jar!
Daisyplayer1: Larry: Hey Yoshi, if you're gonna have some cookies, at least share some with us young Koopalings since you give
Daisyplayer1: them to the older ones!
Daisyplayer1: Larry: Queen Mom's gonna be mad about this...

Super Goomba: Junior: So much for the "Steal Peach's Cookies" plan... **GOOD PRIZE**
Super Goomba: Larry: See, I told you! Junior's translucent!

J-bit: Bowser Junior: What? Hurry up! We haven't got caught yet. Get that face of your... face and take the rest of the cookies!
J-bit: Yoshi: They were... for Grandmother, she's sick!

Jet the Hawk: Larry: HA! I knew there was someone in here! Jr, I told you GO AWAY!

MaskedSheik: Larry: Now, see here Junior, as the Yoshi, using naught but his power of smell, navigates a roomful of cupboards in
MaskedSheik: the dark to find the only cookie jar in the castle.

Metaknight82: Yoshi took the cookie from the cookie jar!
Metaknight82: Yoshi: This isn't what it looks like, guys... I can explain.

Wacky Koopa: Yoshi: What cookies? I'm not stealing cookies. I'm just taking my discs made of baked cookie dough and brown
Wacky Koopa: spots.

Doopliss' twin: Believe it or not, this is actually the reason that Koopas and Yoshis hate each other.

Pete: Boshi: It followed me home. Can I keep him?
Pete: Bowser Jr: Aha! We caught you! Now face the consequences, clean wall! Oh, hi Boshi.

Boxman: Larry: I always thought that the Black Yoshi was evil, but I never thought he was this evil!
Boxman: Yoshi's dark side, stealing cookies and taking candy from babies.
Boxman: Bowser Jr: Ok Yoshi, leave us a few cookies and Mario will never know what happened tonight...

gibsonm496: Yoshi: (I really hope they don't eat me... Is that... drool?!

Mariorulez: Black Yoshi: Aw, crudmonkeys! It's the fuzz!
Mariorulez: Larry: You are under house arrest, Black Yoshi! You have the right to bribe me! Anything offered will be eaten by me
Mariorulez: whether cooked or raw! **GOOD PRIZE**

the game prince: Larry: Hey! I had no idea Koopa Castle had a cookie vault! Huh? What?

Lakitufo: Larry: Aha! I knew it! Black Yoshis really DO exist!

Paper Shadow: Junior and Larry decided to keep the Black Yoshi and name it Garfield because both are very gluttonous.

Shade Koopa: Bowser Jr: Hey, Yoshi, don't steal the cookies, that's our job!
Shade Koopa: Larry: Bowser Jr, why did you have to have a volcano in your head? I totally can't see.
Shade Koopa: Larry: Bowser Jr, unfortunately that's a Baby Yoshi. *sniff* I'm so sad.
Shade Koopa: Bowser Jr: Hey, Yoshi, why did you have to turn of the lights? I'm afraid of the dark, ya know.

Neon Koopa: Bowser Jr: Give us back our cookies, you stupid meanie-head!!!
Neon Koopa: Larry: It's not the torch that's making the light, it's my glorious teeth!
Neon Koopa: Larry: We're the hall monitors! No eating in the halls!!!
Neon Koopa: Bowser Jr: C'mon, give us the cookies, quick so me n' Plant Boy can get home. His hair wilts in dim light.
Neon Koopa: Larry and Bowser Jr. are doing a backwards version of the dance moves from Michael Jackson's "Smooth
Neon Koopa: Criminal".

Got something to tell me? Email me!
Go back to the previous Contests.
Go back to the current Contest.
Go back to Lemmy's Land.